Robert R. McGill Administrative Law Blog on Lawyers.com

FERS & CSRS Federal Disability Retirement from the Office of Personnel Management: Relying on Common Sense

Friday, February 3, 2012 by Robert R. McGill

The problem of relying on "common sense" (as that term is often used and understood) is that such reliance not only reflects a presumption that one possesses that very quality that we deem and recognize as "common sense", but further, that we assume that we have such sense to realize one possesses it, and additionally, that the person to whom such sense is applied also has it.  In preparing, formulating and filing for Federal Disability Retirement benefits from the Office of Personnel Management, it is indeed an arbitrary delegation and assignment of one's case, that the Case Worker would possess that very quality in the process of evaluating, analyzing and reviewing the Federal Disability Retirement application.  Instead, what normally happens is that the OPM Case Worker mechanically applies a sheet containing the "7-part Legal Criteria" and determines whether or not a Federal Disability Retirement application satisfies each of the criteria.  But much of Federal Disability Retirement has to do with subtle implications and "reading between the lines" of a medical report, and coming to a "common sense" conclusion by extrapolating and actually analyzing the connection between one's positional duties and one's medical conditions, and determining whether or not an inconsistency exists.  Further, when the Bracey decision concerning the concept of "Accommodations" is considered, the issue of inconsistency between a Federal or Postal position and the medical condition can be viewed in a proper light and context, with greater clarity.  But to rely upon common sense -- both in one's self, and in someone else -- is a dangerous assumption:  one which proves the old adage about making a donkey out of you and me.

Sincerely, Robert R. McGill, Esquire

Posted at 07:26 AM
Topic: Administrative Law
Lawyers.com Blog

Lawyers.comSM Blog

Get an inside view of
Lawyers.com

Blog Topics

Bloggers

Archives

Recent...