Robert R. McGill Administrative Law Blog on Lawyers.com

     To reiterate: Situational disability can be an issue which can defeat a disability retirement application, precisely because OPM (and if it gets to the MSPB level, the Administrative Judge) can conclude that the Psychiatric disability in question originates and results in response to the hostile workplace environment.   These three concepts are important to understand -- originate, result in, and result "in response to".   A psychiatric condition can originate from a hostile work environment, but as long as the medical condition then pervades beyond the work environment and impacts a person's life through and through, then that alone does not constitute situational disability, because while it may have originated from A, it is not limited to A.  The second concept -- results in -- must be seen in the context of the condition of the psychiatric disability.  Thus, does the (for example) Major Depression or anxiety result solely from the work environment, or does one experience the symptoms while at home, even while away from the work environment?  And thirdly, does the individual experience the symptoms of the psychiatric condition "in response to" his or her exposure to the work environment, or are the symptoms all-pervasive:  i.e., throughout all aspects of the person's life?  To differentiate these three concepts is important in avoiding the pitfalls of situational disability, and in helping to prepare a Psychiatrist in either preparing a medical narrative report, or in his or her testimony before an Administrative Judge at the Merit Systems Protection Board.

Sincerely, Robert R. McGill, Esquire